(Ir)religiosity

View Comments to 'American Idol Shouts to the Lord'

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack to 'American Idol Shouts to the Lord'.

1. I caught wind of this yesterday, but hadn’t seen it. Apparently you can say “Lord” but not “Jesus”… huh.

   

   Jake Bouma

   10 Apr 08 at 3:56 pm
2. I blogged about it here, and left comments over here.

   

   Mud Puppy

   10 Apr 08 at 3:57 pm
3. strange. really strange.

   i actually DO watch the show, but didn’t watch it last night.

   but seriously… this is the strangest strong choice of american idol history.

   i don’t get it.

   

   dave

   10 Apr 08 at 3:57 pm
4. It irks me too. On the GBOD’s Ruach mailing list for church leaders and musicians, we talked about the defining line between worship and performance.

   One comment that was made was this: “Whoever is leading the
   worship also has to be worshiping.”

   So, this was a performance of a worship song, not worship itself.
   - It was written as a worship song.
   - It is supposed to be performed as a worship song.
   - But it is only worship if the worship leader IS worshipping too. And I guarantee the Idol contestants were not worshipping.

   So, it was a performance of a worship song, and if individuals were able to worship during the song, great.

   But it’s the performance aspect of a worship song that irks me a bit.

   

   Jeremy

   10 Apr 08 at 4:01 pm
5. ps. Why aren’t we linking to each other? I’ve just fixed my end…

   

   Mud Puppy

   10 Apr 08 at 4:32 pm
6. @mud puppy. done!

   

   blake

   10 Apr 08 at 4:40 pm
7. @jeremy. i ‘ve got a good mind to blacklist your comment after that twitter stunt yesterday.

   you’re right on. that worship/performance thing has really bothered me over the last few year, so much so that i have a pretty negative view of the “contemporary praise and worship” thing. it just seems really individualistic, shallow and even superficial. i know that’s a gross generalization, but i guess it’s just a personal thing. the sad part is, i think that i continue to lead a “contemporary worship” service on a weekly basis.

   

   blake

   10 Apr 08 at 5:16 pm
8. @blake. Glad you are a man of grace and not going to ban me. In compensation, here’s a video for you (no, really, it is amazing)

   I call most P&W songs “sex with Jesus” songs. Bet you’ll never sing “In the secret” the same way again!

   

   Jeremy

   10 Apr 08 at 9:00 pm
9. @jeremy. well just know that unlike god, my grace is very limited. that’s just how i roll.

   yeah, i “retired” that song a long time ago. “i want to know you more.” seriously. are you kidding me? geez.

   

   blake

   10 Apr 08 at 9:07 pm
10. One more thought on this: ETR has a blog post up on “Are Worship Leaders Performers?” Check it out.

    

    Jeremy!

    16 Apr 08 at 12:46 pm
11. what's with the swaying and fake sincerity?

    

    ChurchETHOS

    1 May 09 at 1:24 am

Leave a Reply